X
Tap here to go to the mobile version of the site.

Support Forum

This thread was closed and archived. Please ask a new question if you need help.

The "ask me every time" option of the privacy settings, regarding cookies, is gone.

Posted

About an hour ago I noticed that the option to "ask me every time" on cookies, regarding privacy, was gone! All that's there, now is always or never. So, I uninstalled Firefox and then installed it, again, but it didn't help. That selection was still gone. I've always used this feature, and now I am very concerned. What happened? How can I get this feature back?

About an hour ago I noticed that the option to "ask me every time" on cookies, regarding privacy, was gone! All that's there, now is always or never. So, I uninstalled Firefox and then installed it, again, but it didn't help. That selection was still gone. I've always used this feature, and now I am very concerned. What happened? How can I get this feature back?

Chosen solution

That's strange. Where are you looking, exactly? this is what I see on the Options page, Privacy panel (screen shot attached).


Edit X-link J99

Please Scroll down this thread for posts relating to Firefox 44 And consider looking at

  • Like many other users I have found the option of "ask every time" re cookies to be very useful and was concerned of it's removal. /questions/1110790
Read this answer in context 1

Additional System Details

Installed Plug-ins

  • Adobe PDF Plug-In For Firefox and Netscape 11.0.13
  • Facebook Video Calling Plugin
  • The plug-in allows you to open and edit files using Microsoft Office applications
  • Shockwave Flash 20.0 r0
  • Adobe Shockwave for Director Netscape plug-in, version 12.1.7.157
  • 5.1.41105.0
  • NPWLPG
  • Yahoo Application State Plugin version 1.0.0.7

Application

  • User Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; WOW64; rv:43.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/43.0

More Information

jscher2000
  • Top 10 Contributor
8693 solutions 71056 answers

Chosen Solution

That's strange. Where are you looking, exactly? this is what I see on the Options page, Privacy panel (screen shot attached).


Edit X-link J99

Please Scroll down this thread for posts relating to Firefox 44 And consider looking at

  • Like many other users I have found the option of "ask every time" re cookies to be very useful and was concerned of it's removal. /questions/1110790
That's strange. Where are you looking, exactly? this is what I see on the Options page, Privacy panel (screen shot attached). --------- Edit X-link J99 Please Scroll down this thread for posts relating to Firefox 44 And consider looking at * Like many other users I have found the option of "ask every time" re cookies to be very useful and was concerned of it's removal. [/questions/1110790]

Modified by John99

Question owner

Oh, I am so very sorry, I just discovered that I was looking in the wrong place for it! I was assuming it was supposed to be in the drop-down box of "accept third-party cookies" (which only gave "Always / From visited / Never. Well, I just now happened to click, by sheer chance, "keep until" which is where the "Ask me every time" was actually located.

Again, I apologize.

Thank you for caring!

Oh, I am so very sorry, I just discovered that I was looking in the wrong place for it! I was assuming it was supposed to be in the drop-down box of "accept third-party cookies" (which only gave "Always / From visited / Never. Well, I just now happened to click, by sheer chance, "keep until" which is where the "Ask me every time" was actually located. Again, I apologize. Thank you for caring!
cor-el
  • Top 10 Contributor
  • Moderator
17472 solutions 157915 answers

Note that the "Ask me" choice for cookies will be removed in Firefox 44+ and will be treated like ACCEPT_NORMALLY (network.cookie.lifetimePolicy = 0).

Note that the "Ask me" choice for cookies will be removed in Firefox 44+ and will be treated like ACCEPT_NORMALLY (network.cookie.lifetimePolicy = 0). *Bug 606655 - Remove "Ask me everytime" cookies option *http://mxr.mozilla.org/mozilla-central/source/extensions/cookie/nsCookiePermission.cpp
hiptech 0 solutions 2 answers

This is most distressing as I've used this option extensively for years. Can someone explain why the "Ask me" choice for cookies will be removed in Firefox 44+?

This is most distressing as I've used this option extensively for years. Can someone explain why the "Ask me" choice for cookies will be removed in Firefox 44+?

Modified by hiptech

jscher2000
  • Top 10 Contributor
8693 solutions 71056 answers

Hi hiptech, I'm not really sure why it was removed, the bug comments seems to indicate it caused crashes for some people, but there may well be documents outside the system that provide more insight.

I personally stopped using it due to the annoying deluge of prompts and switched to Firefox accepting cookies for the current session and manually making exceptions when I wanted a site to be able to set a persistent cookie. This was on top of a base collection of block permissions for third party sites, which you probably also have already. Those stay in effect.

In addition to the built-in cookie management options, there are many add-ons which offer different approaches. For example:

Perhaps someone will bring back "Ask me every time" in a new way that isn't as annoying.

Hi hiptech, I'm not really sure why it was removed, the bug comments seems to indicate it caused crashes for some people, but there may well be documents outside the system that provide more insight. I personally stopped using it due to the annoying deluge of prompts and switched to Firefox accepting cookies for the current session and manually making exceptions when I wanted a site to be able to set a persistent cookie. This was on top of a base collection of block permissions for third party sites, which you probably also have already. Those stay in effect. In addition to the built-in cookie management options, there are many add-ons which offer different approaches. For example: * Self-Destructing Cookies: retains cookies until you close all tabs for that site (or you can indicate that you want to keep a site's cookies): https://addons.mozilla.org/firefox/addon/self-destructing-cookies/ Perhaps someone will bring back "Ask me every time" in a new way that isn't as annoying.
Whatdoiknow 1 solutions 5 answers

Helpful Reply

I too am extremely disappointed that this "OPTION" has be deleted. WTH

I don't want  a zillion cookies tracking my every move. Some are needed but most are not needed. This will be very tedious controlling cookies now, thank you so much.

Reasons I found for deleting this option are childish. I have Never had an issue with that setting nor ever seen a complaint about it.


Rreasons for deleting it are here. https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=469260

If you set the preference for third party cookies to "ask me every time" Firefox displays a modal dialog box for every cookie it encounters. This is bad for a number of reasons:

-It exposes far too much detail about the underlying implementation of the Web

-It forces the user to make a ridiculous number of decisions before visiting a Web site. For instance, amazon.com produces 8 dialog boxes, and ebay.com 15.

-Even informed users will not always have enough information to make an informed choice.


Are you serious?!?!?!? If it for some reason bothers you then just simply don't use it but at least let us that do understand it and use it have the option to do so.

I too am extremely disappointed that this "OPTION" has be deleted. WTH I don't want a zillion cookies tracking my every move. Some are needed but most are not needed. This will be very tedious controlling cookies now, thank you so much. Reasons I found for deleting this option are childish. I have Never had an issue with that setting nor ever seen a complaint about it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Rreasons for deleting it are here. https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=469260 If you set the preference for third party cookies to "ask me every time" Firefox displays a modal dialog box for every cookie it encounters. This is bad for a number of reasons: -It exposes far too much detail about the underlying implementation of the Web -It forces the user to make a ridiculous number of decisions before visiting a Web site. For instance, amazon.com produces 8 dialog boxes, and ebay.com 15. -Even informed users will not always have enough information to make an informed choice. ------------------------------------------------------------------- Are you serious?!?!?!? If it for some reason bothers you then just simply don't use it but at least let us that do understand it and use it have the option to do so.

Modified by Whatdoiknow

cor-el
  • Top 10 Contributor
  • Moderator
17472 solutions 157915 answers

You can check the "Accept third-party cookie" settings and possibly select "From visited".

  • Tools > Options > Privacy > Firefox will: "Use custom settings for history"

You can set network.cookie.thirdparty.sessionOnly to true on the about:config page to make third-party cookies behave as session cookies that expire when Firefox is closed.

You can create a cookie 'allow' exception to keep specific cookies and let the cookies expire when Firefox is closed.

  • Tools > Options > Privacy > "Use custom settings for history"
You can check the "Accept third-party cookie" settings and possibly select "From visited". *Tools > Options > Privacy > Firefox will: "Use custom settings for history" You can set <b>network.cookie.thirdparty.sessionOnly</b> to true on the <b>about:config</b> page to make third-party cookies behave as session cookies that expire when Firefox is closed. *http://kb.mozillazine.org/about:config You can create a cookie 'allow' exception to keep specific cookies and let the cookies expire when Firefox is closed. *Tools > Options > Privacy > "Use custom settings for history"
Elwood_Blues 0 solutions 1 answers

Helpful Reply

Just stumbled upon the same issue. And I'm just flabbergasted for the reasoning behind this.

"It forces the user to make a ridiculous number of decisions" "It exposes far too much detail"

Excuse me, but is this kindergarten?

By removing the option, every user who wants to manage cookies now has to manually edit the exceptions list for each site you want to have cookies permanently stored. That is just... stupid.

Seriously, the person who made the decision to remove the function based on those reasons should be fired.

Just stumbled upon the same issue. And I'm just flabbergasted for the reasoning behind this. "It forces the user to make a ridiculous number of decisions" "It exposes far too much detail" Excuse me, but is this kindergarten? By removing the option, every user who wants to manage cookies now has to manually edit the exceptions list for each site you want to have cookies permanently stored. That is just... stupid. Seriously, the person who made the decision to remove the function based on those reasons should be fired.
jscher2000
  • Top 10 Contributor
8693 solutions 71056 answers

Hi Elwood_Blues, please also submit your comments using the following site:

https://input.mozilla.org/feedback/firefox

Hi Elwood_Blues, please also submit your comments using the following site: https://input.mozilla.org/feedback/firefox
sprocketoctopus 0 solutions 2 answers

I think this a very retrograde step for Firefox!

Yes I can install a cookie manager addon, and yes, I agree with the Bug reported way back in 2008 about the amount of dialog boxes that will pop up on certain sites (like Apple, or microsoft!)

Google is particularly insidious for tracking cookies - and I'm sure you all know they are not just "google.com" etc.

I'ts all about privacy here Mozilla!!!!

I think this a '''very retrograde''' step for Firefox! Yes I can install a cookie manager addon, and yes, I agree with the Bug reported way back in 2008 about the amount of dialog boxes that will pop up on certain sites (like Apple, or microsoft!) Google is particularly insidious for tracking cookies - and I'm sure you all know they are not just "google.com" etc. I'ts all about privacy here Mozilla!!!!
jscher2000
  • Top 10 Contributor
8693 solutions 71056 answers

Hi sprocketoctopus, please also submit your comments using the following site:

https://input.mozilla.org/feedback/firefox

Hi sprocketoctopus, please also submit your comments using the following site: https://input.mozilla.org/feedback/firefox
glnz 2 solutions 42 answers

I cannot believe that Firefox (a) has deleted the "ask me every time" option and (b) didn't tell anyone. Mozilla - are you kidding? This option is the #1 reason I have preferred and contributed to Firefox. What are you trying to do? Imitate Google Chrome? Your excuses for this are flat out wrong, false and misleading. There is no add-on that duplicates this easy to use and easy to understand option. Put it back, and do it now.

I cannot believe that Firefox (a) has deleted the "ask me every time" option and (b) didn't tell anyone. Mozilla - are you kidding? This option is the #1 reason I have preferred and contributed to Firefox. What are you trying to do? Imitate Google Chrome? Your excuses for this are flat out wrong, false and misleading. There is no add-on that duplicates this easy to use and easy to understand option. Put it back, and do it now.

Modified by glnz

glnz 2 solutions 42 answers

By the way, this problem has not been "solved", and the "solved" checkmark should be removed.

By the way, this problem has not been "solved", and the "solved" checkmark should be removed.
jscher2000
  • Top 10 Contributor
8693 solutions 71056 answers

Hi glnz, please also submit your comments using the following site:

https://input.mozilla.org/feedback/firefox

This thread originally was about Firefox 43 and the solution was for Firefox 43.

Discussion about workarounds for the new situation in Firefox 44 should be moved to a new thread. Feel free to start one! This is what I most likely would respond with, but you might get other suggestions so give it a shot:


Unfortunately, the old "Ask me every time" option was removed.

You can set your default to the permission you used most often, for example, for session cookies:

Keep until: I close Firefox

Firefox will continue to apply your accumulated allow/block list, but to choose a non-default setting for a site in the future, you'll need to use one of these methods:

For the site currently indicated in the address bar:

Call up the Permissions panel of the Page Info dialog any of these:

  • right-click a blank area of the page and choose View Page Info > Permissions
  • (menu bar) Tools menu > Page Info > Permissions
  • click the padlock or globe icon to the left of the site address, then the ">" icon, then More Information > Permissions

The "Set Cookies" permission is about 3/4 of the way down the panel.

For other sites:

You can manually create an Exception on the Options page. However, it's probably easier to use an add-on. (I haven't tested any myself.)

Hi glnz, please also submit your comments using the following site: https://input.mozilla.org/feedback/firefox This thread originally was about Firefox 43 and the solution was for Firefox 43. Discussion about workarounds for the new situation in Firefox 44 should be moved to a new thread. Feel free to start one! This is what I most likely would respond with, but you might get other suggestions so give it a shot: ---- Unfortunately, the old "Ask me every time" option was removed. You can set your default to the permission you used most often, for example, for session cookies: Keep until: I close Firefox Firefox will continue to apply your accumulated allow/block list, but to choose a non-default setting for a site in the future, you'll need to use one of these methods: ''For the site currently indicated in the address bar:'' Call up the Permissions panel of the Page Info dialog any of these: * right-click a blank area of the page and choose View Page Info > Permissions * (menu bar) Tools menu > Page Info > Permissions * click the padlock or globe icon to the left of the site address, then the ">" icon, then More Information > Permissions The "Set Cookies" permission is about 3/4 of the way down the panel. ''For other sites:'' You can manually create an Exception on the Options page. However, it's probably easier to use an add-on. (I haven't tested any myself.)
glnz 2 solutions 42 answers

jscher - I disagree. This is the hot thread that already has 50 people with the same issue., and some of them have this issue in FF 44. The FF version is not relevant to the issue. Let's stay here.

Your workaround doesn't work.

Instead of sending me off to do a clone of this important thread, please communicate with your closest buddies in Mozilla and ask them if they've gone out of their minds.

Then, after you've determined which jerk implemented this wrong decision (and without telling anyone!), ask them to put the option back.

And let's stay here until this is resolved.

jscher - I disagree. This is the hot thread that already has 50 people with the same issue., and some of them have this issue in FF 44. The FF version is not relevant to the issue. ''Let's stay here.'' Your workaround doesn't work. Instead of sending me off to do a clone of this important thread, please communicate with your closest buddies in Mozilla and ask them if they've gone out of their minds. Then, after you've determined which jerk implemented this wrong decision (and without telling anyone!), ask them to put the option back. And let's stay here until this is resolved.

Modified by glnz

jscher2000
  • Top 10 Contributor
8693 solutions 71056 answers

Hi glnz, since this is not a hot issue for me and my volunteer time is limited, I will leave it to you and motivated others to make the argument.

Hi glnz, since this is not a hot issue for me and my volunteer time is limited, I will leave it to you and motivated others to make the argument.
glnz 2 solutions 42 answers

Those affected should add Replies here. We need numbers.

Those affected should add Replies here. We need numbers.
grindbert 0 solutions 1 answers

I also am extremely disappointed by this change. It was a feature i used heavily. Without this feature there is no point for me in using FF. This option is crucial to me. I switched to Opera instantly after i found out only to find out that this option doesn't exist there as well.

Comodo Dragon / Pale Moon it is i guess.

if this option comes back i might install FF again. i refuse to use a browser without this option.

Good bye Firefox, you have served me well for years but removing control and security in favor of convenience is something i will not accept.

I also am extremely disappointed by this change. It was a feature i used heavily. Without this feature there is no point for me in using FF. This option is crucial to me. I switched to Opera instantly after i found out only to find out that this option doesn't exist there as well. Comodo Dragon / Pale Moon it is i guess. if this option comes back i might install FF again. i refuse to use a browser without this option. Good bye Firefox, you have served me well for years but removing control and security in favor of convenience is something i will not accept.

Modified by grindbert

jscher2000
  • Top 10 Contributor
8693 solutions 71056 answers

The Cookie Monster extension is an option for those who are willing to let a page load with your default cookie permission, whether it is Allow for Session or Block and then make changes as needed/desired from a drop-down menu.

https://addons.mozilla.org/firefox/addon/cookie-monster/

Sample screen shot attached -- the option to "Apply cookie settings to both HTTP and HTTPS" is turned on, which streamlines the menu. With this option you don't have to set/modify permissions for both HTTP or HTTPS on the same site (why would they be different?).

The Cookie Monster extension is an option for those who are willing to let a page load with your default cookie permission, whether it is Allow for Session or Block and then make changes as needed/desired from a drop-down menu. https://addons.mozilla.org/firefox/addon/cookie-monster/ Sample screen shot attached -- the option to "Apply cookie settings to both HTTP and HTTPS" is turned on, which streamlines the menu. With this option you don't have to set/modify permissions for both HTTP or HTTPS on the same site (why would they be different?).
John99 971 solutions 13138 answers

I will close this as the OP related to Fx43, and although marked solved the solution does not apply to the current Fx44 Release.

Readers & posters in this thread may be interested in a current Thread relating to Firefox 44

  • Like many other users I have found the option of "ask every time" re cookies to be very useful and was concerned of it's removal. /questions/1110790
I will close this as the OP related to Fx43, and although marked solved the solution does not apply to the current Fx44 Release. Readers & posters in this thread may be interested in a current Thread relating to Firefox 44 * Like many other users I have found the option of "ask every time" re cookies to be very useful and was concerned of it's removal. [/questions/1110790]