Windows 10 reached EOS (end of support) on October 14, 2025. If you are on Windows 10, see this article.

Search Support

Avoid support scams. We will never ask you to call or text a phone number or share personal information. Please report suspicious activity using the “Report Abuse” option.

Learn More
Archived

Cannot send emails in Thunderbird for Mac after update

Montrealer

Updated from Thunderbird 115.10.1 to 116 and now cannot send emails -- on two different machines: one an iMac (OS 18.5), the other a MacBook (OS 17.x).

Ten seconds after hitting "Send", we get an error message saying "Sending of the message failed. An error occurred while sending mail: Outgoing server (SMTP) error. The server responded: EHLO [13 character string] internal error AUP#EML-005."

Our settings and password have not changed, and they are all correct according to our ISP. Tech Support at the ISP says they are not blocking our emails -- although that is what a "EML-005" error usually means.

(In fact we ARE able to send emails via the ISP's Webmail interface, no problem. But this interface is old, very clunky, and not a satisfactory solution to our problem.)

VPN is off. Problem persists when Firewall is off.

Have tried a clean re-install. Did not help.

Have reverted to previous version of the app and Profile folder, using Time Machine backups from before the update. Problem persists! (How can this be??)

ALSO: We have a MacBook Pro that has not been updated. It is still running 115.10.1 -- and it can still send emails in Thunderbird, over the same network connection. All SMTP settings are exactly the same. How can this be? I tried copying the Profile folder from the unaffected MacBook Pro to the iMac. This did not fix the problem.

What to do?

UPDATE (22 July): Tried connecting via my iPhone's hotspot: the iMac CAN send email via the hotspot, no error. The SMTP error only occurs when I try to send mail from via my cable modem. Called our ISP (Videotron), but they swear it cannot be a problem with them, because I am able to send mail via their Webmail interface. I am skeptical, but they state that the "internal error AUP#EML-005" is not coming from their SMTP server, that it must be generated erroneously by Thunderbird.

Updated from Thunderbird 115.10.1 to 116 and now cannot send emails -- on two different machines: one an iMac (OS 18.5), the other a MacBook (OS 17.x). Ten seconds after hitting "Send", we get an error message saying "Sending of the message failed. An error occurred while sending mail: Outgoing server (SMTP) error. The server responded: EHLO [13 character string] internal error AUP#EML-005." Our settings and password have not changed, and they are all correct according to our ISP. Tech Support at the ISP says they are not blocking our emails -- although that is what a "EML-005" error usually means. (In fact we ARE able to send emails via the ISP's Webmail interface, no problem. But this interface is old, very clunky, and not a satisfactory solution to our problem.) VPN is off. Problem persists when Firewall is off. Have tried a clean re-install. Did not help. Have reverted to previous version of the app and Profile folder, using Time Machine backups from before the update. Problem persists! (How can this be??) ALSO: We have a MacBook Pro that has not been updated. It is still running 115.10.1 -- and it can still send emails in Thunderbird, over the same network connection. All SMTP settings are exactly the same. How can this be? I tried copying the Profile folder from the unaffected MacBook Pro to the iMac. This did not fix the problem. What to do? UPDATE (22 July): Tried connecting via my iPhone's hotspot: the iMac CAN send email via the hotspot, no error. The SMTP error only occurs when I try to send mail from via my cable modem. Called our ISP (Videotron), but they swear it cannot be a problem with them, because I am able to send mail via their Webmail interface. I am skeptical, but they state that the "internal error AUP#EML-005" is not coming from their SMTP server, that it must be generated erroneously by Thunderbird.
Attached screenshots

Modified by Montrealer

All Replies (1)

Thats a SMTP error I believe - you may want to double check your smtp scripts/protcols/password/port or something else - this is above my paygrade and I'm not on a mac or windows.