Windows 10 will reach EOS (end of support) on October 14, 2025. For more information, see this article.

Search Support

Avoid support scams. We will never ask you to call or text a phone number or share personal information. Please report suspicious activity using the “Report Abuse” option.

Learn More

filter not working well dev build

  • 3 replies
  • 0 have this problem
  • 8 views
  • Last reply by Matt

more options

Hi: I don't know where this issue should go, admins pls decide. T-bird 140.3.1 esr 64b. W11p laptop, asus f17 w/i7 alder lake from around 2021. This is "important" cause I don't know where the issue lies (hardware speeds or software?).

-bbmde1@googlegroups.com

This has been an off & on issue for almost decades now. I really can't change the email specifics at all. This group started as a yahoo group, which had my email in hotmail.

The filter only works sometimes. Today is another instance of the filter not working. Sometimes the filter works, and then with a new t-bird update, it fails, but not always immediately.

The filter is to: move the "bbmde1" msgs to a folder still located in the hotmail account listed on my laptop as residing in the hotmail acct. But I've noted in the filter, that these sends from the bbmde owner, are from her gmail acct (not assoc w/yahoo/hotmail, for yrs).

The sometimes working workaround is to look at another t-bird acct on screen (like archives), then click back to "inbox" - unified folders, classic view - and sometimes (hence this email) the msgs go to the right acct/folder w/o further input, sometimes not. Sometimes I have to physically delete the msg.

Is this an "update" failure, that is, I must re-create the same filter, or create a new one to get the filter to work?

"Working" means, on opening, t-bird moves the "bbmde1" msgs to its own "bbmde" folder automatically, no needed input from me. T-bird doesn't leave these "bbmde1" msgs in "inbox."

Thank you.

Hi: I don't know where this issue should go, admins pls decide. T-bird 140.3.1 esr 64b. W11p laptop, asus f17 w/i7 alder lake from around 2021. This is "important" cause I don't know where the issue lies (hardware speeds or software?). -bbmde1@googlegroups.com This has been an off & on issue for almost decades now. I really can't change the email specifics at all. This group started as a yahoo group, which had my email in hotmail. The filter only works sometimes. Today is another instance of the filter not working. Sometimes the filter works, and then with a new t-bird update, it fails, but not always immediately. The filter is to: move the "bbmde1" msgs to a folder still located in the hotmail account listed on my laptop as residing in the hotmail acct. But I've noted in the filter, that these sends from the bbmde owner, are from her gmail acct (not assoc w/yahoo/hotmail, for yrs). The sometimes working workaround is to look at another t-bird acct on screen (like archives), then click back to "inbox" - unified folders, classic view - and sometimes (hence this email) the msgs go to the right acct/folder w/o further input, sometimes not. Sometimes I have to physically delete the msg. Is this an "update" failure, that is, I must re-create the same filter, or create a new one to get the filter to work? "Working" means, on opening, t-bird moves the "bbmde1" msgs to its own "bbmde" folder automatically, no needed input from me. T-bird doesn't leave these "bbmde1" msgs in "inbox." Thank you.

All Replies (3)

more options

so from what I understand you are implicitly deleting the mail from one account and then adding it to another, both being IMAP accounts you can not actually move from one to another.

Is the filter set to execute after junk processing. this occurs after a complete local download of the message body, Usually filters work when the meta data excluding the message body is received adding the delay for spam processing allows for time to get all the data you are going to be moving instead of some of it.

Helpful?

more options

Hi Matt, read your reply, thanks. 1) I don't see the process as a deletion The bbmde mail is sent to my gmail acct. It stays there. I merely send the bbmde mail to the local folder (still) in its original hotmail folder on my w11 laptop. When the filter works, that's what I want it to do. It works, sometimes, hence post here. 2) Following your suggestion, I did just chg the filter to act "after" junk mail weedout. We'll see how that works. Thank you.

Helpful?

more options

linusr said

Hi Matt, read your reply, thanks. 1) I don't see the process as a deletion

Email is in WallysWorld@Somewhere.com you "move" it to Franko@wallyworld.com If the account is IMAP that means the mail is deleted from WallysWorld@Somewhere.com. IMAP has no way to move an email from one account to another.

Certainly if the account is POP there is only local copies of mail involved and they can be moved. But as you have not said what mail protocol you use I have assumed the default (IMAP)

What you have just said is you copy the mail and make a new copy retaining the old. This iat odds with your initial post were you said.

linusr said

sometimes I have to physically delete the msg.

That does not sound like making a new copy and retaining the old in the account it came into.

SO we can be sure I am not lost and we are on the same page. Please check the account settings for the account the messages are coming for and the account they are going to and confirm if they are IMAP or POP

Unless you have issues with your antivirus program, quite likely they are poor products when put under a microscope for efficiency and stability. You almost certainly have an IMAP account in there as they are the ones most likely to demonstrate unstable filtering unless it is done after junk processing. Please prove me wrong and determine if you need an exception in your antivirus product for the Thunderbird profile folder to allow Thunderbird to actually work without the incessant and lengthy delays scanning causes. Updates from filters can't be saved because the scanning is taking longer per folder than the time between accesses.

Helpful?

Ask a question

You must log in to your account to reply to posts. Please start a new question, if you do not have an account yet.