Search Support

Avoid support scams. We will never ask you to call or text a phone number or share personal information. Please report suspicious activity using the “Report Abuse” option.

Learn More

Account woes after removing Virtual Identity.

  • 3 replies
  • 1 has this problem
  • 6 views
  • Last reply by Matt

more options

I never could get Virtual Identity or Correct Identity to consistently work predictably, so after many months twiddling them, I removed them. Then I needed to test what I had to do to live without them. There's a problem.

(The email addresses and accounts are fakes, but you'll get the idea.)

When I send this message to myself at a different account:

To: to@gmail.com
Reply-To: replyto@gmail.com

me.to gets the message fine. When I compose a reply, I expect this:

To: replyto@gmail.com
Reply-To: to@gmail.com

But I get this:

To: replyto@gmail.com
Reply-To: to+arf@gmail.com

to+arf@gmail.com was a virtual identity. So it appears that something is screwed. But what is screwed and how would I fix it?

Grateful for any ideas, Mark.

I never could get Virtual Identity or Correct Identity to consistently work predictably, so after many months twiddling them, I removed them. Then I needed to test what I had to do to live without them. There's a problem. (The email addresses and accounts are fakes, but you'll get the idea.) When I send this message to myself at a different account: To: to@gmail.com Reply-To: replyto@gmail.com me.to gets the message fine. When I compose a reply, I expect this: To: replyto@gmail.com Reply-To: to@gmail.com But I get this: To: replyto@gmail.com Reply-To: to+arf@gmail.com to+arf@gmail.com was a virtual identity. So it appears that something is screwed. But what is screwed and how would I fix it? Grateful for any ideas, Mark.

All Replies (3)

more options

I'm posting this again because this editor goofed and there's no way to edit a post.

I never could get Virtual Identity or Correct Identity to consistently work predictably, so after many months twiddling them, I removed them. Then I needed to test what I had to do to live without them. There's a problem.

(The email addresses and accounts are fakes, but you'll get the idea.)

When I send this message to myself at a different account:

To: to@gmail.com
Reply-To: replyto@gmail.com


to@gmail.com gets the message fine. When I compose a reply, I expect this:

To: replyto@gmail.com
Reply-To: to@gmail.com


But I get this:

To: replyto@gmail.com
Reply-To: to+arf@gmail.com


to+arf@gmail.com was a virtual identity. So it appears that something is screwed. But what is screwed and how would I fix it?

Grateful for any ideas, Mark.

more options

Never mind. I didn't realize that TBird also has identies.

Currently, identities are tied to account whereas I need a separate identity for each recipient. I'll work on this further and post anew if I can't find a solution.

more options

Check your outgoing server (SMTP) entries in account settings. I guess you have one there with the wrong user name.