Marko said
philipp said
- support for full themes will be removed - bug 1222546 (no timescale on this was publicised yet; just looking at the install numbers on AMO this will be affecting upwards to a million users)
WTF? If we do that, Firefox will die! We have already lost many users because we don't fix Flash hangs and rather redesign Add-ons Manager. Customizability is one of the main reasons why some other people insist on Firefox, and we can't lose them too.
"Heavyweight themes" and "full themes" are terrible misnomers. What is really being removed is XUL support for addons, which means current themes that do anything other than put a picture behind the UI will break. However, there is no intention to remove the ability to have themes that change UI elements- they will just have to do it without XUL. This was announced months ago.
The functionality to do that doesn't exist yet. But it will before XUL support is removed from addons.
It really is unfortunate that this bug was given the name that it was, that it was created without being dependent on a blocker bug for implementing themeing support in the new WebExtensions API, and that Firefox PM hasn't been more communicative about their dedication to working with the addons (ie. themeing) community to update the WebExtensions API. But I do expect all of these issues to be fixed soon.
So please don't worry too much. But please do continue make your concerns known in a nice way. We'll get through this together. :)
''Marko [[#post-67296|said]]''
<blockquote>
''philipp [[#post-67278|said]]''
<blockquote>
* support for full themes will be removed - [https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1222546 bug 1222546] (no timescale on this was publicised yet; just looking at the install numbers on AMO this will be affecting upwards to a million users)
</blockquote>
WTF? If we do that, Firefox will die! We have already lost many users because we don't fix Flash hangs and rather redesign Add-ons Manager. Customizability is one of the main reasons why some other people insist on Firefox, and we can't lose them too.
</blockquote>
"Heavyweight themes" and "full themes" are terrible misnomers. What is really being removed is XUL support for addons, which means '''current''' themes that do anything other than put a picture behind the UI will break. However, there is no intention to remove the ability to have themes that change UI elements- they will just have to do it without XUL. This was announced months ago.
The functionality to do that doesn't exist yet. But it will before XUL support is removed from addons.
It really is unfortunate that this bug was given the name that it was, that it was created without being dependent on a blocker bug for implementing themeing support in the new WebExtensions API, and that Firefox PM hasn't been more communicative about their dedication to working with the addons (ie. themeing) community to update the WebExtensions API. But I do expect all of these issues to be fixed soon.
So please don't worry too much. But please ''do'' continue make your concerns known in a nice way. We'll get through this together. :)