OTENET (Greece) POP3 account receives mail fine, but outgoing smtp.otenet.gr fails with Reject, id=xxxxx - SPAM
Hi everyone,
I have been using a OTENET (Cosmote, Greece) e-mail account (apel50@otenet.gr) in Thunderbird on a laptop for years. But since a couple of weeks I have a problem with outgoing mail. No changes in configuration.
=> Incoming mail: Works still perfectly via POP3 (mail.otenet.gr, port 995, SSL/TLS).
=> Outgoing mail: Consistently fails on mailgate.otenet.gr. Tested on port 465 with SSL/TLS and port 587 with STARTTLS, as well as via different network connections/hotspots, and just to be sure also on smtp.otenet.gr. The following error:
"Verzenden van het bericht is mislukt. Er is een fout opgetreden bij het verzenden van e-mail. De mailserver antwoordde: Reject, id=18742-18 - SPAM. Controleer het bericht en probeer het opnieuw."
I have already contacted Cosmote support, and they verified that the account status is completely fine and that smtp.otenet.gr is indeed the correct and active outgoing server. Even a simple, plain-text test email with a normal sentence gets rejected immediately by their server-side filter (amavisd / SpamAssassin).
Could this be related to a specific header, authentication method, or sender-identity mismatch in Thunderbird when communicating with modern Telekom/Cosmote SMTP infrastructure? Any advice on what to check would be greatly appreciated!
Warm regards, Anna
Toutes les réponses (7)
This is purely a server-side problem. There is nothing inherent in messages that Thunderbird creates that would cause them to be identified as spam - obviously, since if that were the case we'd see it happening everywhere.
Not that this is definitive, but here's what Thunderbird thinks should be the proper server settings for a otenet.gr email address. How do they compare with yours?
Incoming server type: IMAP Server: imap.telekom-mail.gr Port: 993 Security: SSL/TLS Username: your otenet.gr email address Authentication: Normal Password
Outgoing: smtp Server: mailgate.telekom-mail.gr Port: 587 Security: STARTTLS Username: your otenet.gr email address Authentication: Normal Password
Do you use Thunderbird's signature feature? It's unlikely, but if the signature includes something the server doesn't like, say an image or binary file, it might trigger a block.
Hi Lin, Thanks for your very prompt response! Much appreciated.
A couple of remarks and responses to your questions:
- I use POP3, not IMAP. In my mountain village we're often confronted with electricity and/or internet breakdown, so I don't use anything in the cloud. All's on my laptop (and well backed-up!).
- I'm still an otenet account, and verified with the Cosmote helpdesk that the otenet addresses have to be used, not the telekom-mail addresses. Besides, I also tried with the telekom addresses (just to be sure) and that didn't work either 😢.
- I use the signature feature, but it's flat text.
- On the account is the feature to test the connection, and it's succesful. I've also inspected their certificate, and it's valid until February 2027 with DigiCert Inc.
- If the Cosmote server would be at fault, there'd be a lot of commotion, for Thunderbird is quite popular and at least half of the Greeks use Cosmote.
So, I'm still at a loss what to do next... It has to be something specific for my account, otherwise either you had had a lot of questions in the Thunderbird community, or Cosmote would have been overrun.
I did see similar questions about the SMTP server in the forum, but as they used other parties, I couldn't really relate. Maybe I'm just not technical enough to see the similarities.
Should you have any more ideas, they're welcome! Thanks again, Anna
I think you will find us mostly at a loss as well as the rejection is being made by you mail provider.
There is however a couple of things that might help you specifically. The "id=18742-18 - SPAM" is an internal event identifier. If you can get hold of someone that has access with your provider they can look that number up and get a specific reason they rejected the email.
The other is simply generic suggestions.
- Try sending mail without a signature attached. They are the greatest cause of false positives and it is often related to images in the signature. things like the facebook pinterest etc logos are usually sourced via a web search and have been used by spammers in the past for instance.
- Look at the content of your emails. Are they mostly image? This is another triggering factor. Try sending a mail with only text.
Now I must point out that IMAP or POP3 is irrelevant to sending mail. When you click send the mail is sent to an SMTP server which functions entirely independently of the incoming parts. While those using Microsoft Accounts do use other protocols, in this instance you outgoing mail is SMTP. Always
The next issue is the configuration of the SMTP server. You mentioned Assassin specifically. As I understand it it contains an option to "block" email originating from home IP address as they are not "mail servers" I have seen these types of rule misapplied by providers frequently (mostly US providers) in the past.
Do you have a VPN? It might be that the server is considering all connection attempts from outside the providers network to be attempted spam. (I doubt the NPN will have an endpoint in the providers network.)
Hi Matt,
Thank you too for your response. I've tried without signature and only some text. Alas the problem persists. I don't have a VPN (anymore).
Anyway you and Lin pointed me to reach out to the Cosmote (provider) helpdesk and not rest until I've reached a real technician (2nd or 3rd line). You've given me munition and for this I'm very grateful.
Thank you, Anna
Just a passing comment: if you have more than one account, you may be using the wrong SMTP server setting.
Hi David, Thanks for the suggestion. Yes, I have more than 1 account. What would be the correct SMTP server setting then? I still think it must be a problem at the provider's side, for everything went fine for years and suddenly overnight it didn't work anymore. And since you all convinced me it's not in Thunderbird, I'll have to connect Cosmote. (Which I dread because it costs a LOT of time to reach them and then to convince the first-line helpdesk that I really need a second-line technician and then to be transferred correctly without the connection ending and having to start all over again.) Thank you for your response. Kind regards, Anna
It' only a possibility. Sometime, when there are two or more accounts, one account ends up using the SMTP server of the other account, creating a situation where emails from that account are rejected, while the other account works as desired. You can check this by
- clicking 'account settings' pane
- highlight in left side the account in question
- now, in lower right, click the 'edit outgoing server' button
- check that the email address in that pane matches the email address for that account. If it does, then this not the cause.