What can I expect from Export/Import?
I recently setup a PC running Ubuntu with Firefox and Tbird. I normally use Pegasus Mail under Windows, and Tbird has a similar look I'm familiar with. But I got into a mess with Export/Import. My default Tbird install was for an IMAP account and she had already setup folders, received mail, created folders and posted mail into a local folder folder tree. I hadn't realised this and decided I prefered POP which was running on my other mail clients. In my merry-go-round of abandoning IMAP which I thought would be just changing server credentials but was so hard I started from scratch with a clean Tbird install. I used Export/Import and each time Import was creating duplicate local Folders until my original folder tree became a real mess. It does the same even though I only now have a POP server account. I'm not convinced deleting duplicate folders with mail content actually deletes them either, because folder size inside the profile appears unchanged.
At the same time as using Export I also made backup copies of the profile in the hard drive Tbird folder. When I retrieved a profile backup and copied it back to the Tbird folder, the folder tree was what I expected from a restored backup - Exactly as it was before, with all local folders containing emails.
I am wondering now if Tbird Export/Import isn't what I would regard as Backup/Restore, but appends folders to existing as duplicates without replacing and overwriting? Anything to help me understand the Export/Inport function would be helpful? Thanks
All Replies (4)
You should never try to change and existing IMAP account in Thunderbird to POP or vice versa. The safe method is to create another account alongside the existing one.
If you're talking about the Export tool found in the Tools menu, it makes a copy of your entire Profile folder. It's basically the same as manually copying the profile folder. When you import a backed up folder using the Import tool and it finds existing folders it will make a new folder alongside of it. It will not overwrite them.
You could, instead, manually restore a profile folder with a previously backed up copy of it, in which case you would be in the same state as when you made the backup.
Thanks. I didn't succeed changing from IMAP to POP so recreated the account with POP server credentials. But then I had folders containing mail I wanted back in the same tree structure for the POP account. I tried making a copy of 'Local Folders' from my IMAP backup and replacing 'Local Folders' in the new profile created as a POP account but that seemed to go wrong.
When I looked at the backed up profile as an IMAP account I could see message content and a folder size but gave up trying to recover anything. Just glad there wasn't much there to lose. I was also puzzled by 'New Mail' because I have 2 entries, the second is in Local Folders. After creating the new POP account I looked inside the profile and could see an entry for both new mail and 'POP. my email account'. I think I worked out the folder POP.my email account is where new mail gets loaded each time the mail server is polled. After much internet searching and trying to delete the second New mail folder appearing in local Folders, the AI robot said this was normal and to just ignore it? My POP server settings are set to poll and update the new mail inbox every 5 minutes so I assume if I moved any new mail into the New mail inbox under Local Files, they become local and aren't deleted to stay in sync when the mail server is polled?
Now I want to be sure I can recover a Local folder by copying from a backup profile to the working profile, or recover a mail message from a profile backup without deleting what's in the active profile. I don't think the last option is doable unless there's a utility that can read and extract messages from folders inside a saved profile? I did notice Import was creating new Local folders for each import - Local Folder1.... 2 etc where individual messages could probably be opened and moved to the default Local Folder.
You may find it more straightforward to import individual folders at will to use the add-on " ImportExportTools NG".
https://addons.thunderbird.net/en-US/thunderbird/addon/importexporttools-ng/
Thanks again, I'll experiment with the addon. I don't trust Backup/Restore until I've tested the routine and understand what it does. No good having to use it after an event and be disappointed.
The Backup/Restore I rely on to always work reliably independent of local OS is disc and sector image based. Tbird Export/Import seems to use its own way and I'm not even sure now if replacing the local profile with a previous saved backup is the same as using Export/Import or my disc image backup restore method? You mentioned leaving the IMAP profile as is and creating a new entry. I think when I tried this using the same email address with POP server settings, Tbird objected becauses it already had a valid (IMAP) connection. Which it would have, since it was booted online. Immediately I'm thinking mail I want preserved is locked into the IMAP configuration and I can't recover or move it?
Could you or another member clarify a folder tree setup under IMAP and POP? I always thought folders containing mail under 'Local' could be migrated by copy and paste, irrespective of whether mail was originally saved to them from IMAP or POP server configuration and it was only the default inbox that could lose mail?