Windows 10 will reach EOS (end of support) on October 14, 2025. For more information, see this article.

Sök i support

Akta dig för supportbedrägerier: Vi kommer aldrig att be dig att ringa eller skicka ett sms till ett telefonnummer eller dela personlig information. Rapportera misstänkt aktivitet med alternativet "Rapportera missbruk".

Läs mer

Does FIDO U2F in Thunderbird 60 actually work with a email account?

  • 1 svar
  • 1 har detta problem
  • 6 visningar
  • Senaste svar av tanstaafl

more options

The release notes for Thunderbird version 60 state that FIDO U2F is supported. Unfortunately it doesn't mention any email providers that it works with. It appears that it might not just be a question of whether Thunderbird supports U2F, the email provider might need to do some work to make it work too, despite them already supporting U2F with webmail.

Reading https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1444101 (Enable FIDO U2F for Thunderbird) I get the impression that the person who implemented the support never verified it ever worked with a email account. Instead they tested its U2F conformance using https://u2f.bin.coffee/ and then stated "Google would then need to make sure their login flow accommodates Thunderbird users with U2F tokens."

1. Has anybody actually gotten U2F to work with a Thunderbird Gmail account ? https://landing.google.com/advancedprotection/

2. How about other email providers such as Fastmail ? My main account is a Fastmail IMAP account and I would like to make it more secure using U2F. But I don't want to buy a Yubico U2F device (I would actually need two, one as a backup) until its clearer whether it might work. I have asked in the Fastmail support forum whether it works but I suspect that if I get any answer, they'll suggest I ask Mozilla.

The release notes for Thunderbird version 60 state that FIDO U2F is supported. Unfortunately it doesn't mention any email providers that it works with. It appears that it might not just be a question of whether Thunderbird supports U2F, the email provider might need to do some work to make it work too, despite them already supporting U2F with webmail. Reading https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1444101 (Enable FIDO U2F for Thunderbird) I get the impression that the person who implemented the support never verified it ever worked with a email account. Instead they tested its U2F conformance using https://u2f.bin.coffee/ and then stated "Google would then need to make sure their login flow accommodates Thunderbird users with U2F tokens." 1. Has anybody actually gotten U2F to work with a Thunderbird Gmail account ? https://landing.google.com/advancedprotection/ 2. How about other email providers such as Fastmail ? My main account is a Fastmail IMAP account and I would like to make it more secure using U2F. But I don't want to buy a Yubico U2F device (I would actually need two, one as a backup) until its clearer whether it might work. I have asked in the Fastmail support forum whether it works but I suspect that if I get any answer, they'll suggest I ask Mozilla.

Alla svar (1)

more options

I submitted a support ticket to Fastmail and got a reply today. "We currently do not support this. We hope to support this in the future, but don't have any timeline on this now, sorry."

So far I'm the only person who responded to the question about using Yubikey (a FIDO U2F device) with Gmail in https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1230131 asked two days ago. U2F support is beginning to look as useless as the support for detecting email scams.