📣 Help shape Firefox by joining our Test Days event on July 21–27 to test the Firefox Semantic History Search in Firefox Beta 142

חיפוש בתמיכה

יש להימנע מהונאות תמיכה. לעולם לא נבקש ממך להתקשר או לשלוח הודעת טקסט למספר טלפון או לשתף מידע אישי. נא לדווח על כל פעילות חשודה באמצעות באפשרות ״דיווח על שימוש לרעה״.

מידע נוסף

Command-option-up and command-option-down keyboard shortcuts were stolen from websites

more options

I regularly use a website which intercepts command-option-up and command-option-down for its own navigation. This is a central part of my workflow with this website, and without it it becomes completely unusable.

After updating to Firefox 140.0.4, these shortcuts are now used by the browser to switch tabs. I have not found any way to configure this. Am I missing some obscure way to do this or is this just impossible?

I imagine this change was made to support vertical tabs, but I'm not using those, so the command-option-left and command-option-right shortcuts make more sense for my horizontal setup. (I don't use those shortcuts either, though- I use ctrl-tab and ctrl-shift-tab!)

I regularly use a website which intercepts command-option-up and command-option-down for its own navigation. This is a central part of my workflow with this website, and without it it becomes completely unusable. After updating to Firefox 140.0.4, these shortcuts are now used by the browser to switch tabs. I have not found any way to configure this. Am I missing some obscure way to do this or is this just impossible? I imagine this change was made to support vertical tabs, but I'm not using those, so the command-option-left and command-option-right shortcuts make more sense for my horizontal setup. (I don't use those shortcuts either, though- I use ctrl-tab and ctrl-shift-tab!)

כל התגובות (6)

more options

I found where this change was made: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1965273

Based on the diff, it does look like there is simply no way to configure this. Is this the right place to request that this be configurable?

I've also filed a bug here: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1976320

השתנתה ב־ על־ידי rpjohnst

Helpful?

more options

No this is not the right place - sounds like key bindings on a mac. What do you think firefox can do?

Helpful?

more options

These are not keybindings implemented by macOS. They are keybindings implemented by Firefox, running on macOS. See the bugzilla link.

Helpful?

more options

Most keyboard shortcuts can be intercepted and repurposed by websites. There are just a few that Firefox doesn't allow sites to override (like Command+W to close the current tab). Since it's not your site, it's not obvious how you could enhance its code to avoid changing tabs. Could you mention the problem to the site?

Helpful?

more options

> There are just a few that Firefox doesn't allow sites to override (like Command+W to close the current tab).

This is the whole problem with these particular new shortcuts. If Firefox allowed them to be intercepted and repurposed then the site would have simply continued working.

Helpful?

more options

rpjohnst said

> There are just a few that Firefox doesn't allow sites to override (like Command+W to close the current tab). This is the whole problem with these particular new shortcuts. If Firefox allowed them to be intercepted and repurposed then the site would have simply continued working.

I don't have a Mac so I can't test. Also, I don't know what site you're using, so I can't look at their code.

Helpful?

פרסום שאלה

You must log in to your account to reply to posts. Please start a new question, if you do not have an account yet.