Join the AMA (Ask Me Anything) with the Firefox leadership team to celebrate Firefox 20th anniversary and discuss Firefox’s future on Mozilla Connect. Mark your calendar on Thursday, November 14, 18:00 - 20:00 UTC!

Avatar for Username

Search Support

Avoid support scams. We will never ask you to call or text a phone number or share personal information. Please report suspicious activity using the “Report Abuse” option.

Learn More

Ova tema je arhivirana. Pitajte drugo pitanje ako vam je potrebna pomoć.

Firefox does not install on Android on a chromebook with no touchscreen

  • 3 odgovori
  • 4 ima ovaj problem
  • 17 views
  • Posljednji odgovor poslao Student_T

Ozpeter
Ozpeter
more options

Firefox app does not follow Google best practice guidelines - see

https://developer.android.com/distribute/best-practices/engage/optimize-for-chromebook.html

"Best practices

Update your app's manifest file. Account for some key hardware and software differences between Chromebooks and Android devices. For example, adjust the settings so that the android.hardware.touchscreen feature is not required. Also ensure that none of the sensors are required if you want to run on any Chromebook regardless of the sensors it supports. "

The FF manifest file still contains ""android.hardware.touchscreen" set to "Yes" - it should be set to "no" so that Firefox can be installed on Chromebooks having non-touchscreen screens. I would have thought this would be the work of a moment for a developer. And it would help to bring Firefox right into the heart of Chrome territory!  ;)

Firefox app does not follow Google best practice guidelines - see https://developer.android.com/distribute/best-practices/engage/optimize-for-chromebook.html "Best practices Update your app's manifest file. Account for some key hardware and software differences between Chromebooks and Android devices. For example, adjust the settings so that the android.hardware.touchscreen feature is not required. Also ensure that none of the sensors are required if you want to run on any Chromebook regardless of the sensors it supports. " The FF manifest file still contains ""android.hardware.touchscreen" set to "Yes" - it should be set to "no" so that Firefox can be installed on Chromebooks having non-touchscreen screens. I would have thought this would be the work of a moment for a developer. And it would help to bring Firefox right into the heart of Chrome territory! ;)

All Replies (3)

James
James
  • Top 25 Contributor
  • Moderator
more options

The Android Firefox is not being made with Chromebooks in mind as it is made for actual Android tablets and phones.

There is only two bugs for Android Firefox on Chromebooks. So Chromebooks is not a priority. Bug 1387936 - Chromebook running Play Store listed as "not compatible with this version." Bug 1335510 - Touchpad scrolling doesn't work on Chromebook

Ozpeter
Ozpeter Vlasnik pitanja
more options

Thanks for your prompt response.

Bug 1387936 - Chromebook running Play Store listed as "not compatible with this version."

This is in essence what I'm reporting - the code change necessary to fix this is to set "android.hardware.touchscreen" to "Yes" - End of bug, and I doubt whether that would cause any problems for phone or tablet users who almost by definition have touchscreens anyway.

Google are thinking in terms of Chromebooks becoming replacements for tablets, from what I read. It seems to me worth FF keeping up with this trend, especially as the effort required should - I repeat, should - be minimal. If I could install FF on my Chromebook then I could see whether the other bug you mention applies, and whether I can see a possible cause - it shouldn't happen (judging by other apps on CB which are fine).

And of course, it must be tempting to take FF into the heart of 'enemy' territory, But maybe you guys have minds above such pettiness!  :)

Student_T
Student_T
more options

A "C-" workaround is to download Firefox and run with screensize enlarged and Request Desktop Site = Off. 4-way arrows do work and permit somewhat jerky scrolling. Bookmarks functions/actions are unavailable. Chromebooks were the fastest growing device type in 2016, 2017, 2018 to date in part because unlike most tablets, they have USB 2.0,3.0, and 3C ports for unlimited storage offline, provide typing as well as mouse and touchscreen navigation, are cheaper, and are administrated easily en masse for schools, libraries, and many service organizations. Not making Chromebooks a FF priority is like countries preparing to fight WWII by focusing on WWI technologies.