Search Support

Avoid support scams. We will never ask you to call or text a phone number or share personal information. Please report suspicious activity using the “Report Abuse” option.

Learn More

Why is the FROM email address changing when I reply to people?

  • 7 replies
  • 1 has this problem
  • 206 views
  • Last reply by Matt

more options

I have multiple email addresses. I save and move all emails to one email address. When I reply, the "FROM" address always defaults to that email address in which I am saving the emails. So for example, if someone emails me at email1@email.com and I save that email in email2@email.com, then later respond to that email, it uses email2@email.com as the "FROM" email.

Shouldn't it reply using the ORIGINAL email address?

I have multiple email addresses. I save and move all emails to one email address. When I reply, the "FROM" address always defaults to that email address in which I am saving the emails. So for example, if someone emails me at email1@email.com and I save that email in email2@email.com, then later respond to that email, it uses email2@email.com as the "FROM" email. Shouldn't it reply using the ORIGINAL email address?

Chosen solution

NotBatman said

Shouldn't it reply using the ORIGINAL email address?

No That is what the identities part of the account setup is for, to specify the identities to use when replying. I suggest you have a look at this topic https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1239772

Read this answer in context 👍 0

All Replies (7)

more options

Chosen Solution

NotBatman said

Shouldn't it reply using the ORIGINAL email address?

No That is what the identities part of the account setup is for, to specify the identities to use when replying. I suggest you have a look at this topic https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1239772

more options

Is there any way to fix this via some extension or something so I can have it the way I want?

Matt said

NotBatman said
Shouldn't it reply using the ORIGINAL email address?

No That is what the identities part of the account setup is for, to specify the identities to use when replying. I suggest you have a look at this topic https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1239772

more options

You can define the replying identity for each account with this add-on:

https://addons.thunderbird.net/en-us/thunderbird/addon/correct-identity/

Note the version for TB 60 stated in the latest review (change the downloaded zip extension to xpi to install).

more options

NotBatman said

Is there any way to fix this via some extension or something so I can have it the way I want?

The link I gave you provided significant detail on how to configure your account to work correctly. Instead of that you want an add-on. How about just set up your accounts the correct way.

Set up identities or use an add-on that might or might not work after the next update. I know which I would be using.

more options

Question: If I add an identity to my default email address to correct this issue, will the receiver of the email ever see it came from my original identity/default email address?

more options

Matt said

NotBatman said
Is there any way to fix this via some extension or something so I can have it the way I want?

The link I gave you provided significant detail on how to configure your account to work correctly. Instead of that you want an add-on. How about just set up your accounts the correct way.

Set up identities or use an add-on that might or might not work after the next update. I know which I would be using.

Question: If I add an identity to my default email address to correct this issue, will the receiver of the email ever see it came from my original identity/default email address?

more options

To expand this topic somewhat. Outlook/Hotmail/MSN ignore what you set in your mail client and replace it with the information they have for your primary email address.

There are other providers that will also do that. So no one here can offer a definitive answer because there are two things involved and only you know who provides the mail service and if they actually comply with the standards. the Microsoft subsidiary clearly does not.