X
Tocca qui per la versione per piattaforma mobile del sito.

Forum di supporto

DOH potential security risk message

Inserita

When trying DNS over https in in a neetwork that uses googles DNS 8.8.8.8 and 8.8.4.4 I configured FF as follows set network.trr.mode=3 set network.trr.bootstarpaddress=8.8.8.8 set network.trr.uri=https://dns.google/dns-query

Then I went to https://1.1.1.1/help knowing full well that I am use googles DOH and not cloudflare expecting cloudflare web site to tell me I am not using there services with results being all negative.

Instead FF reported that "Warning potential security problem ahead". See enclosed If I am using Googles DOH values and I go to a cloudgflare site why would FF flag the site as a security risk? Keeping in mind FF appears to be working for other sites in the DOH configuration for Google with no visible problems.

When trying DNS over https in in a neetwork that uses googles DNS 8.8.8.8 and 8.8.4.4 I configured FF as follows set network.trr.mode=3 set network.trr.bootstarpaddress=8.8.8.8 set network.trr.uri=https://dns.google/dns-query Then I went to https://1.1.1.1/help knowing full well that I am use googles DOH and not cloudflare expecting cloudflare web site to tell me I am not using there services with results being all negative. Instead FF reported that "Warning potential security problem ahead". See enclosed If I am using Googles DOH values and I go to a cloudgflare site why would FF flag the site as a security risk? Keeping in mind FF appears to be working for other sites in the DOH configuration for Google with no visible problems.
Immagini allegate

Soluzione scelta

The network is a library in Canada, Toronto area. I didn't believe that the library would filter a specific 1.1.1.1 address and not other DOH sites. But It appears that is the case because I tried another device on that network and then I tried it on another public network and it worked.

I will have to put this question to the Library as to why the filter? Not that I expect an answer

Leggere questa risposta nel contesto 0
Citazione

Dettagli aggiuntivi sul sistema

Applicazione

  • User Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10.13; rv:68.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/68.0

Ulteriori informazioni

jscher2000
  • Top 10 Contributor
8632 soluzioni 70597 risposte

Can you click the Advanced button for more information about why the certificate verification failed?

Can you click the Advanced button for more information about why the certificate verification failed?
È stato utile questo messaggio? 1
Citazione
cor-el
  • Top 10 Contributor
  • Moderator
17407 soluzioni 157253 risposte

Risposta utile

1.1.1.1 would normally redirect you to a server in your vicinity using anycast, so there might be a domain mismatch for the certificate after the redirect.

1.1.1.1 would normally redirect you to a server in your vicinity using anycast, so there might be a domain mismatch for the certificate after the redirect.
È stato utile questo messaggio? 1
Citazione

Risposta utile

The certificate failed because it was not HTTPs so the connection was not secure. But strangely I was not able to connect using CloudFlare DOh value only with Googles DOH value shown in this web site "https://github.com/curl/curl/wiki/DNS-over-HTTPS#publicly-available-servers"

The certificate failed because it was not HTTPs so the connection was not secure. But strangely I was not able to connect using CloudFlare DOh value only with Googles DOH value shown in this web site "https://github.com/curl/curl/wiki/DNS-over-HTTPS#publicly-available-servers"
È stato utile questo messaggio? 1
Citazione
Eldar Value 4 soluzioni 45 risposte

Those settings are working:

about:config?filter=network.trr

network.trr.bootstrapAddress > 8.8.8.8 network.trr.confirmationNS > dns.google network.trr.credentials > dns.google network.trr.disable-ECS > false network.trr.early-AAAA > true network.trr.mode > 3 network.trr.uri > https://dns.google.com/experimental

after set, restart firefox and enjoy :)

'''Those settings are working:''' about:config?filter=network.trr network.trr.bootstrapAddress > 8.8.8.8 network.trr.confirmationNS > dns.google network.trr.credentials > dns.google network.trr.disable-ECS > false network.trr.early-AAAA > true network.trr.mode > 3 network.trr.uri > https://dns.google.com/experimental '''after set, restart firefox and enjoy :)'''
È stato utile questo messaggio? 1
Citazione

Utente che ha posto la domanda

I have already stated the settings I used. I have already stated that google DOH worked.

Why does cloudflare the default used by FF not work?

I have already stated the settings I used. I have already stated that google DOH worked. Why does cloudflare the default used by FF not work?
È stato utile questo messaggio? 1
Citazione
philipp
  • Top 25 Contributor
  • Moderator
5287 soluzioni 23361 risposte

again, please click on advanced on the error page to see what's the error code and possibly inspect the failing certificate...

again, please click on advanced on the error page to see what's the error code and possibly inspect the failing certificate...
È stato utile questo messaggio?
Citazione

Utente che ha posto la domanda

You dont seem to understand. No certificate was obtained as shown in my enclosure.

Why would cloudflare site be blocked and not google? Why is it I could not get through to cloudflare when google DOH was working?

You dont seem to understand. No certificate was obtained as shown in my enclosure. Why would cloudflare site be blocked and not google? Why is it I could not get through to cloudflare when google DOH was working?
È stato utile questo messaggio?
Citazione
jscher2000
  • Top 10 Contributor
8632 soluzioni 70597 risposte

Hi Mace2, on the error page, there is an Advanced button -- the gray one next to the large blue one. That Advanced button opens a panel with more technical information about the problem. I don't think you can diagnose the issue without that.

Hi Mace2, on the error page, there is an Advanced button -- the gray one next to the large blue one. That Advanced button opens a panel with more technical information about the problem. I don't think you can diagnose the issue without that.
È stato utile questo messaggio?
Citazione

Utente che ha posto la domanda

Enclosed is the advance tab. Keep in mind the google DOH values are set and work. But the cloudflare web site 1.1.1.1/help did not work

Enclosed is the advance tab. Keep in mind the google DOH values are set and work. But the cloudflare web site 1.1.1.1/help did not work
È stato utile questo messaggio?
Citazione
jscher2000
  • Top 10 Contributor
8632 soluzioni 70597 risposte

I'm looking at the domains of the certificate provided to Firefox in your screenshot and I wonder whether your service provider may not permit IP address URLs, or at least this one. Otherwise, why would that certificate be showing up?

I'm looking at the domains of the certificate provided to Firefox in your screenshot and I wonder whether your service provider may not permit IP address URLs, or at least this one. Otherwise, why would that certificate be showing up?
È stato utile questo messaggio?
Citazione

Soluzione scelta

The network is a library in Canada, Toronto area. I didn't believe that the library would filter a specific 1.1.1.1 address and not other DOH sites. But It appears that is the case because I tried another device on that network and then I tried it on another public network and it worked.

I will have to put this question to the Library as to why the filter? Not that I expect an answer

The network is a library in Canada, Toronto area. I didn't believe that the library would filter a specific 1.1.1.1 address and not other DOH sites. But It appears that is the case because I tried another device on that network and then I tried it on another public network and it worked. I will have to put this question to the Library as to why the filter? Not that I expect an answer
È stato utile questo messaggio? 0
Citazione
jscher2000
  • Top 10 Contributor
8632 soluzioni 70597 risposte

Do you think they filter 1.1.1.1 in particular, or filter IP address URLs in general?

Do you think they filter 1.1.1.1 in particular, or filter IP address URLs in general?
È stato utile questo messaggio?
Citazione

Utente che ha posto la domanda

I think a greater question is why Cloidflare DOH was filtered over Google DOH

I think a greater question is why Cloidflare DOH was filtered over Google DOH
È stato utile questo messaggio? 0
Citazione
jscher2000
  • Top 10 Contributor
8632 soluzioni 70597 risposte

So if you aren't using DOH you can access https://1.1.1.1/help on that same network?

So if you aren't using DOH you can access https://1.1.1.1/help on that same network?
È stato utile questo messaggio?
Citazione

Utente che ha posto la domanda

I am using DOH. I am using googles DOH server. The librayr is filtering only cloudflare DOH.

the configuration network.trr.mode=3 ensures only DOH is being used.

I am using DOH. I am using googles DOH server. The librayr is filtering only cloudflare DOH. the configuration network.trr.mode=3 ensures only DOH is being used.
È stato utile questo messaggio? 0
Citazione
Richiedi supporto

Bisogna accedere al proprio account per rispondere nelle discussioni. Se non si possiede ancora un account, inserire una nuova richiesta.