Search Support

Avoid support scams. We will never ask you to call or text a phone number or share personal information. Please report suspicious activity using the “Report Abuse” option.

Learn More

Cuireadh an snáithe seo sa chartlann. Cuir ceist nua má tá cabhair uait.

Attempting to seach for a bookmark (in Firefox Library) causes "not responding" message, altho search is completed in 8 minutes. Help?

  • 29 freagra
  • 1 leis an bhfadhb seo
  • 106 views
  • Freagra is déanaí ó Bob

more options

Hi...Every time I attempt to search for a bookmark by clicking "show your bookmarks" (or Ctrl/shift/b), then selecting "all bookmarks", then attempting to type something in the search box, it freezes...and just allows me to press enter, it then turns the "x" in the top right red, and gives a "Not responding" message next to Library(in the top left)..I can still click the red x to cancel the search.

I say attempting to do a search, as it only allows me to type up to 4 (is the most) letters in the search box...its often just one letter before it freezes, and the curser turns into a spinning blue circle....If i just leave it for around 8 minutes,(after pressing enter) it then lists my bookmarks with the search criteria I had used, and the "Not responding" message disappears....and the machine goes back to normal

I have tried removing all my addons and extensions, tried renaming my prefs.js file, but it still hangs and takes 8 minutes.

I havent as yet done a reinstall of Firefox without any of my personal data, or tried a refresh.

The laptop is an HP i7 16gb ram, Win 10 Pro 64bit 1909, Firefox 76.0.1...with all updates present.

Réiteach roghnaithe

Well, I finally managed to delete ALL the duplicate bookmark files and folders....

To show the amount of bookmarks I accumulated during this process, I checked the size of my previously saved bookmarks.json files and my bookmarks.html files that I had saved from different days while working on this.............. At the time I started this process my .json file was 50,144 kb, after using one of the apps it went up to 100,396kb....2 days ago when I finished manually deleting the duplicates the size of this file was a mere 764kb. NO wonder my "search" was hampered........... At roughly the same times I created the .html files....at the start this file was 172,531kb, later on it more than doubled to 345,790kb, and after my manual delating it dropped to 6,458kb...

My search now is instant, and theres no freezing or lag......which was my main problem that prompted this "ask for help" post...

Unfortunately I didnt manage to get an answer on here that solved the problem, or any indication why it happened in the first place, but I will now keep an eye on my bookmarks.json and bookmarks.html for any disproportional increases, so that it doesn't happen again...

I'd like to thank the contributors to this thread, as I did learn a couple of new things from their posts, even though it didn't solve the problem.

I will close the thread now as "Problem Solved"

Read this answer in context 👍 0

All Replies (20)

more options

I dont know why this has been posted on the US questions page...I am in the UK.

more options

Cheers, Bob, I think all the English posts go into one forum, so everyone with any kind of English will see your post.

I suspect there is some odd issue with your Places database, the file that stores bookmarks and history. Before taking further action, could you make a safety backup and export. The following articles have the steps:

Do those seem to be an ample size? You can actually open the exported HTML page in a tab to see what's in there.

- - - -

Then try the built-in database maintenance utility on Firefox's Troubleshooting Information page. You can open that using any of these methods:

  • "3-bar" menu button > "?" Help > Troubleshooting Information
  • (menu bar) Help > Troubleshooting Information
  • type or paste about:support in the address bar and press Enter

Near the bottom, there is a section titled Places Database -- that's the file which stores history and bookmarks. Click the button labeled Verify Integrity. There may be a 10-15 second delay before results appear.

If all is well, the report that appears below the button should start with:

> Task: checkIntegrity
+ The places.sqlite database is sane
+ The favicons.sqlite database is sane

Does yours say that, or something else? You can select and copy the report, and then paste it into a reply for review and comment.

After the databases are cleaned up, any improvement with the search time?

more options

Hi... Apologies for the delay in replying...Its been a bit hectic over here for the past couple of days...I managed to do the first two steps, creating the back up and creating an HTML file of my bookmarks, and then being able to look into it on my desktop. I can see the same folder time after time...

Before I did this, I did a search on a random word that I know I had created a bookmark in the past...As usual it took the standard 8 minutes, and what I found was, 22 incidences of this word and ALL were identical bookmarks, making me think, could I have 22 copies of every bookmark I have ever saved?...I went onto find that apparently (by running my mouse over the restore button) I have over 170,000 bookmarks......could this be the simple answer...This is as far as I have gone at the moment...altho will read further into your reply after I send this.

more options

Hi Bob, sometimes the Sync service can cause extreme bookmark duplication. This may be a little complicated to clean up while you are still Sync'ing your bookmarks. You can use the Options page to adjust Sync settings so that bookmarks are not sync'd while you clean up.

more options

I think(thought) I have Sync disabled, as I only use Firefox on the one machine, so didnt need it, altho it could have been on, on my previous machine(a month ago)...I will check the setting....Do I have to clean up manually, or have I missed an instruction.

Syncing is marked as: OFF

I checked the integrity of the Places Database and the first 3 lines are the same as you mention.

more options

I have found what appears to be a Mozilla recommended Bookmarks clean up tool.....its been running for 5 minutes....so will see what it reports.

more options

It says there are 2024 duplicates...theres is one I have noticed is duplicated 86 times....

more options

Is it possible that the 2024 duplicates means that 2024 original bookmarks have been duplicated, and as in the example above, some up to(or even more than) 86 times...meaning there could be well over 100,000 duplicates in total..

Apologies for the short replies...

more options

The name of an automatically created JSON bookmarks backup in the bookmarkbackups folder includes a total item count (folders and separators included) and an hash value to prevent saving the same backup more than once. You also see this count in the Restore menu drop-down list.

  • bookmarks-YYYY-MM-DD_<item count>_<hash>.jsonlz4.
  • Bookmarks -> Show All Bookmarks -> Import & Backup -> Restore
more options

Hi...thanks for that...I mentioned above I noticed a count of over 170,000 after hovering my mouse ove the Restore command. It is the amount of actual duplicates that I am trying to find out......and get rid of safely.

Athraithe ag Bob ar

more options

Hi Bob, I have never heard of that many bookmarks. Could you make a fresh JSON Backup and see whether the Verify Integrity routine results in a smaller file?

more options

The file indicates that the number of bookmarks is the same.....but...I havent acted on any results as yet....should i use the Bookmarks clean up extension to delete all the duplicates, and then rename my old file(in case it goes wrong), then create a new Json backup.

more options

Isn't there a JSON backup available that has a more realistic bookmarks count ?

more options

By the way, the number on the Restore menu is an item count, including bookmarks, folders, and separators, and perhaps other things. So the real number of bookmarks could well be much lower if there are "garbage" items in the database that are getting saved in the backup files.

more options

I can't seem to create another Json backup....The last 2 I created were both the same size in kb...How do I see what is in the files.......and how do i know if I have garbage or not...I think I'll restart Firefox again...

more options

My last 3 backups are all 50,144 kb each....

Athraithe ag Bob ar

more options

Should I use the bookmarks clean up extension to get rid of the duplicates, and then backup

more options

I think the de-duplicating extension is worth a try. I fear it might choke on the volume, but I don't have a better suggestion at the moment.

more options

Before I do this, should I have done something that makes you think that the number of bookmarks should have reduced...Have i missed something out...if I havent, why, with what I have done above, should it have cured my problem...AFAIK I havent made a command to get rid of any duplicates.

Athraithe ag Bob ar

more options

Are the duplicates located in the same folder or are full folders duplicated?

Extensions use JavaScript to do their work and cleaning up 170.000 bookmarks via JavaScript will likely take a very long time.

  1. 1
  2. 2