X
Tap here to go to the mobile version of the site.

Fóram Tacaíochta

Locate a bookmark in library folders tree

Postáilte

Hello. In my bookmarks library I have a lot of folders organized in a tree with multiple branches themselves organized in hierarchic levels. Sometimes I don't find the bookmark I want to use by browsing my tree, probably because I didn't put it in the right location in the tree. I can find it by the "Search bookmarks" function but this function doesn't provide the bookmark location in the tree (and I don't see any other way to locate it). Thus I can't correct the bookmark location error in the tree.

Is there a way to locate a bookmark in library folders tree ?

Regards. j-p

Hello. In my bookmarks library I have a lot of folders organized in a tree with multiple branches themselves organized in hierarchic levels. Sometimes I don't find the bookmark I want to use by browsing my tree, probably because I didn't put it in the right location in the tree. I can find it by the "Search bookmarks" function but this function doesn't provide the bookmark location in the tree (and I don't see any other way to locate it). Thus I can't correct the bookmark location error in the tree. Is there a way to locate a bookmark in library folders tree ? Regards. j-p

Réiteach roghnaithe

You can open this bookmark in a tab, possible in "Work Offline mode". If you click the highlighted star on the location bar then you can check via the Folder line where in the folder tree this bookmark is located (second down arrow and use the scroll bar).

Read this answer in context 1
Luaigh

Tuilleadh mionsonraí faoin chóras

Breiseáin Shuiteáilte

  • Shockwave Flash 32.0 r0

Feidhmchlár

  • User Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64; rv:71.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/71.0

Tuilleadh Eolais

RobertJ
  • Top 10 Contributor
107 réiteach 1182 freagra

Freagra Cabhrach

Hi j-p_FF, This question has been asked often and, as far as I know, there aren't too many ways to locate a bookmark in your library.

There are some alternative methods: Search for the bookmark and when it's found drag it to a location where you know it is, then, put it where you would like it to be.

Backup your bookmarks as an html. Open the file in Firefox and search (Ctrl+F) for your bookmark. You will see which folder it is in.

Hi j-p_FF, This question has been asked often and, as far as I know, there aren't too many ways to locate a bookmark in your library. There are some alternative methods: Search for the bookmark and when it's found drag it to a location where you know it is, then, put it where you would like it to be. Backup your bookmarks as an html. Open the file in Firefox and search (Ctrl+F) for your bookmark. You will see which folder it is in.
An bhfuil an freagra seo cabhrach? 1
Luaigh
cor-el
  • Top 10 Contributor
  • Moderator
17671 réiteach 159860 freagra

Réiteach Roghnaithe

You can open this bookmark in a tab, possible in "Work Offline mode". If you click the highlighted star on the location bar then you can check via the Folder line where in the folder tree this bookmark is located (second down arrow and use the scroll bar).

You can open this bookmark in a tab, possible in "Work Offline mode". If you click the highlighted star on the location bar then you can check via the Folder line where in the folder tree this bookmark is located (second down arrow and use the scroll bar).
An bhfuil an freagra seo cabhrach? 1
Luaigh
RobertJ
  • Top 10 Contributor
107 réiteach 1182 freagra

cor-el said

You can open this bookmark in a tab, possible in "Work Offline mode". If you click the highlighted star on the location bar then you can check via the Folder line where in the folder tree this bookmark is located (second down arrow and use the scroll bar).

That's a much easier method!

''cor-el [[#answer-1272647|said]]'' <blockquote> You can open this bookmark in a tab, possible in "Work Offline mode". If you click the highlighted star on the location bar then you can check via the Folder line where in the folder tree this bookmark is located (second down arrow and use the scroll bar). </blockquote> That's a much easier method!
An bhfuil an freagra seo cabhrach? 0
Luaigh
quartz 0 réiteach 2 freagra

same question here - chrome has a menu option of "show in folder" - firefox needs the same thing?

same question here - chrome has a menu option of "show in folder" - firefox needs the same thing?
An bhfuil an freagra seo cabhrach?
Luaigh
jscher2000
  • Top 10 Contributor
8837 réiteach 72222 freagra

quartz said

same question here - chrome has a menu option of "show in folder" - firefox needs the same thing?

It is on the wish list somewhere in the bug tracking system. Until then, need to use a workaround.

''quartz [[#answer-1272910|said]]'' <blockquote> same question here - chrome has a menu option of "show in folder" - firefox needs the same thing? </blockquote> It is on the wish list somewhere in the bug tracking system. Until then, need to use a workaround.
An bhfuil an freagra seo cabhrach? 1
Luaigh
cd5609 0 réiteach 5 freagra

Hi everyone. I have the same problem. I have a copious amount of bookmarks all organized into Parent / Child directories. While it doesn't happen often, there are times when I need to know a particular bookmark resides within the Bookmarks tree. In Firefox it's virtually impossible. Within almost every other browser, they offer a "Show in Folder" option that will route you directly to the bookmark's folder. It can be very frustrating when I need to locate the bookmark's directory.

Thanks!

Hi everyone. I have the same problem. I have a copious amount of bookmarks all organized into Parent / Child directories. While it doesn't happen often, there are times when I need to know a particular bookmark resides within the Bookmarks tree. In Firefox it's virtually impossible. Within almost every other browser, they offer a "Show in Folder" option that will route you directly to the bookmark's folder. It can be very frustrating when I need to locate the bookmark's directory. Thanks!
An bhfuil an freagra seo cabhrach?
Luaigh

Úinéir na ceiste

Thanks a lot to all of you ! +++

Indeed the most convenient way to workaround the gap is cor-el's solution. It will be very useful for me. My_Cheese_Is_Slippin' 's solution is time consuming but elegant.

It is on the wish list jscher2000 said, but how to make FF developpers taking this shortcoming in account ? Because it is an annoying gap and it seems quite easy to correct (It doesn't request a lot of code nor modification).

j-p

Thanks a lot to all of you ! +++ Indeed the most convenient way to workaround the gap is cor-el's solution. It will be very useful for me. My_Cheese_Is_Slippin' 's solution is time consuming but elegant. It is on the wish list jscher2000 said, but how to make FF developpers taking this shortcoming in account ? Because it is an annoying gap and it seems quite easy to correct (It doesn't request a lot of code nor modification). j-p

Athraithe ag j-p_FF ar

An bhfuil an freagra seo cabhrach?
Luaigh
the-edmeister
  • Top 25 Contributor
  • Moderator
5419 réiteach 40417 freagra

j-p_FF said

It is on the wish list jscher2000 said, but how to make FF developpers taking this shortcoming in account ? Because it is an annoying gap and it seems quite easy to correct (It doesn't request a lot of code nor modification).

If you think it's so easy, how about stepping up and coming up with an add-on / extension for the rest of the world?

It's been this way since Firefox 3.0 (June 17, 2008) was released with the 'new' Places database system. Over the ensuing years, there have been a number of 3rd party extensions available for users to install (related to what's known as Parent Folder), but as of Quantum Firefox 57 the ability of what an extension can do is very limited vs. the older Legacy extension rules and API's. Displaying the "Parent Folder" doesn't seem to be available any longer, as no API exists. I guess or we would have that type of extension available now, 14 versions after the Quantum era began.

So, no that isn't easy to fix beyond what the developers are willing to do as far as adding it to Firefox or what type of API the developers are willing to add to Firefox so that extension developers can do as they did from Firefox 3.0 up thru Firefox 56.


One other thing that too many long term users don't think about is that one of the key new features with Places is the Tags feature. Which iirc was to allow users to categorize their bookmarks by using Tags, and lessen the need for a hierarchical order using nested folders for classifying bookmarks for easy retrieval. I never bothered with the Tags feature because extensions for Parent Folder existed very soon after Places came about; that is until those extensions didn't exist any longer. But hey,no biggie for me as I am using an old version of Firefox from 2015 for the most important things I do on the internet, other than banking and for YouTube.

''j-p_FF [[#answer-1273676|said]]'' <blockquote> It is on the wish list jscher2000 said, but how to make FF developpers taking this shortcoming in account ? Because it is an annoying gap and '''it seems quite easy to correct (It doesn't request a lot of code nor modification)'''. </blockquote> If you think it's so easy, how about stepping up and coming up with an add-on / extension for the rest of the world? It's been this way since Firefox 3.0 (June 17, 2008) was released with the 'new' Places database system. Over the ensuing years, there have been a number of 3rd party extensions available for users to install ''(related to what's known as Parent Folder)'', but as of Quantum Firefox 57 the ability of what an extension can do is very limited vs. the older Legacy extension rules and API's. Displaying the "Parent Folder" doesn't seem to be available any longer, as no API exists. I guess or we would have that type of extension available now, 14 versions after the Quantum era began. So, '''no''' that isn't easy to fix beyond what the developers are willing to do as far as adding it to Firefox or what type of API the developers are willing to add to Firefox so that extension developers can do as they did from Firefox 3.0 up thru Firefox 56. ------------- One other thing that too many long term users don't think about is that one of the key new features with Places is the '''Tags''' feature. Which iirc was to allow users to categorize their bookmarks by using Tags, and lessen the need for a hierarchical order using nested folders for classifying bookmarks for easy retrieval. I never bothered with the Tags feature because extensions for Parent Folder existed very soon after Places came about; that is until those extensions didn't exist any longer. But hey,no biggie for me as I am using an old version of Firefox from 2015 for the most important things I do on the internet, other than banking and for YouTube.
An bhfuil an freagra seo cabhrach? 0
Luaigh
cor-el
  • Top 10 Contributor
  • Moderator
17671 réiteach 159860 freagra
See also: *https://addons.mozilla.org/firefox/addon/bookmark-search-plus-2/
An bhfuil an freagra seo cabhrach?
Luaigh

Úinéir na ceiste

Thank you very much cor-el. j-p

Thank you very much cor-el. j-p
An bhfuil an freagra seo cabhrach?
Luaigh
cd5609 0 réiteach 5 freagra

Hi @Cor-el. Thank you for sharing. I remember this plugin from year ago! Unfortunately read the description listed on the plugin:

"This is a Web Extension add-on version of the old "Bookmark search plus" XUL extension published by Alice0775, not working anymore in Firefox 57+, which was very useful."

As @the-edmeister was referencing: I wonder why the FF developers chose not to include Parent Folder query within Quantum 57+....?

Hi @Cor-el. Thank you for sharing. I remember this plugin from year ago! Unfortunately read the description listed on the plugin: "This is a Web Extension add-on version of the old "Bookmark search plus" XUL extension published by Alice0775, not working anymore in Firefox 57+, which was very useful." As @the-edmeister was referencing: I wonder why the FF developers chose not to include Parent Folder query within Quantum 57+....?
An bhfuil an freagra seo cabhrach?
Luaigh
cor-el
  • Top 10 Contributor
  • Moderator
17671 réiteach 159860 freagra

The name of the parent folder is easily available, but the problem is getting the path to this folder that requires to go backward until you are at one of the root folder. This backtracking is a costly procedure and can add quite extra time to finish the query with a lot of bookmarks that are deeply nested.

See:

  • Bug 469421 - Add a folder column to search results for bookmarks in the library

Please do not comment in bug reports
https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/page.cgi?id=etiquette.html

You can vote for a bug to show your interest
https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/page.cgi?id=voting.html

The name of the parent folder is easily available, but the problem is getting the path to this folder that requires to go backward until you are at one of the root folder. This backtracking is a costly procedure and can add quite extra time to finish the query with a lot of bookmarks that are deeply nested. See: *[https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=469421 Bug 469421] - Add a folder column to search results for bookmarks in the library Please do not comment in bug reports<br>https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/page.cgi?id=etiquette.html You can vote for a bug to show your interest<br>https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/page.cgi?id=voting.html
An bhfuil an freagra seo cabhrach?
Luaigh
Cuir ceist

You must log in to your account to reply to posts. Please start a new question, if you do not have an account yet.