Search Support

Avoid support scams. We will never ask you to call or text a phone number or share personal information. Please report suspicious activity using the “Report Abuse” option.

Learn More

If a Thunderbird Address Book list contains one bad address, mail does not go to any recipients. Correct? Is there a workaround?

  • 4 replies
  • 1 has this problem
  • 4 views
  • Last reply by Matt

more options

Have created a New List in TB Address Book. Some 100 recipients. On sending I get an error message saying that a particular address has been rejected. It appears that the message was then not sent to the other 99 either. Is this so, if so seems a design flaw? If there a workaround for this? (In fact, the rejected address is perfectly valid and a message sent separately goes through without problem).

Have created a New List in TB Address Book. Some 100 recipients. On sending I get an error message saying that a particular address has been rejected. It appears that the message was then not sent to the other 99 either. Is this so, if so seems a design flaw? If there a workaround for this? (In fact, the rejected address is perfectly valid and a message sent separately goes through without problem).

All Replies (4)

more options

Contacted my ISP (Media Temple) and the problem does not seem to be on their end

Modified by spmcc123

more options

is a send fails, it fails.

A better answer would be to use an address book, not a list. Why? because then you do not have this problem, can filter mail based on the member of that address book. You can not filter on the members of a mailing list.

The draw backs. Typing the list name does not work for addressing

Using the contact pane in the compose windows you click the first entry, hold shift and click the last entry and then click the relevant button below.

Alternatively use the mail merge add-on and send personalized emails to the list. Much nicer.

more options

Thanks for the Mail Merge suggestion. That is indeed much more elegant.

Your response ... use an address book, not a list... and the related suggestions confuse me. TB Address Book allows one to create a New List and creating and then selecting that list (in bcc in most cases) has worked most times (and it is way simpler than finding the desired addresses from the contact pane each time).

In this case, the design flaw seems to be that one unresolvable address led TB to abort sending to all recipients... So, yes, ...if a send fails, it fails..., but I was wondering about the why...

more options

spmcc123 said

In this case, the design flaw seems to be that one unresolvable address led TB to abort sending to all recipients... So, yes, ...if a send fails, it fails..., but I was wondering about the why...

It is in the nature of SMTP servers that send mail. The mail client gives it the list of email addresses, it says no one is dead and closes the connection send aborted is the short summary.

Email works in a very defined space and Thunderbird can not do what the server refuses to do. That sending framework is refered to as an RFC, and the one for SMTP is to be found here. https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc2821