Firefox freezing showing frozen image of recently viewed flash objects, and repeatedly crashing
Firefox repeatedly freezes after 30 minutes or so of use, and strangely when freezing it shows a blank page but with freeze frames recently opened YouTube videos and other flash objects, although it may not be all specific to flash. I can't remember exactly but there may have been some non-flash things showing too, but as far as I'm aware it was flash. It keeps doing this repeatedly and finally crashes. If I could give a number of how many times I've had to go through these repeated crashes, they have happened about 500-1000 times in the last 6-ish months. I can't go a day without them. They happen numerous times a day.
And here's the bit that stumps me. I've did the normal extension troubleshooting procedure, but even when every single plugin has been disabled at one point, it still crashes, so no extension can be the problem (also these crashes started about a year ago and the plugins and extensions hadn't been causing many problems before then). I also tested plugins, disabling any I didn't need and thought could be causing a problem, but it still crashed. I have even uninstalled and reinstalled flash, and updated it numerous times in the hope that the crashes would stop. But they haven't. I have EVEN switched from Firefox Beta (which I was in when it started) to Firefox (which still caused crashes) and now to Aurora, which, as you guessed it, STILL causes crashes. I can be on any page at all and it will crash. I have sent hundreds and hundreds of angered crash reports, no update or fix has been given that has helped the problem. I'm pretty desperate for answers at this point.
Below are all the crashes that have happened this month.
bp-3cf15d06-0af3-4c27-af30-fab682140408 08/04/2014 5:24 PM bp-993c4891-3988-4041-900c-a229c2140408 08/04/2014 2:46 PM bp-60010b1f-0c6c-4c5a-bd55-306962140407 07/04/2014 8:37 PM bp-224b5e85-e936-413c-bf51-4bf6b2140406 06/04/2014 8:58 PM bp-hr-20140406-d20e5ab4-457e-41d5-86b6-f9da20581a1c 06/04/2014 8:38 PM bp-3a88b0a5-9c23-4f5e-a0b9-47ff62140405 05/04/2014 8:05 PM bp-d9ee2ea8-de92-4e3a-8ae7-d36492140405 05/04/2014 11:37 AM bp-ba89ab53-3934-4909-9e5e-70d492140404 04/04/2014 11:11 PM bp-2555d35d-d58f-4460-bff3-02d3c2140404 04/04/2014 9:19 PM bp-ccc842cb-eeb1-4897-8115-3577b2140403 03/04/2014 11:27 PM bp-fefea139-37c7-476e-924b-eddbc2140403 03/04/2014 4:25 PM bp-hr-20140402-e73f3f8f-bed7-4ae0-b8e2-821a73ab9520 02/04/2014 6:31 PM bp-5c00902a-526c-4b76-95df-a08dc2140401 01/04/2014 10:45 PM bp-4d355b0b-0701-4870-bf26-fbd732140401 01/04/2014 5:39 PM
(If you find these on Mozilla crash stats, beware of strong language in the user comments. I was pretty angry when they happened.)
Please help, thanks.
Modified by cor-el
Additional System Details
- Shockwave Flash 12.0 r0
- The QuickTime Plugin allows you to view a wide variety of multimedia content in Web pages. For more information, visit the QuickTime Web site.
- Next Generation Java Plug-in 10.51.2 for Mozilla browsers
- NPRuntime Script Plug-in Library for Java(TM) Deploy
- Adobe Shockwave for Director Netscape plug-in, version 188.8.131.52
- Adobe Shockwave for Director Netscape plug-in, version 184.108.40.206
- User Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.0; rv:30.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/30.0
bp-hr-20140406-d20e5ab4-457e-41d5-86b6-f9da20581a1c 06/04/2014 8:38 PM bp-hr-20140402-e73f3f8f-bed7-4ae0-b8e2-821a73ab9520 02/04/2014 6:31 PM
(These are the hang reports that didn't show correctly in the above post.
Your patience is remarkable. I would have been posting here before the 20th crash. (Also, I've probably said worse things to my computer.)
The 4 most recent reports indicate that Firefox is running out of memory. In one case, it shows 90% of system memory used, which is borderline, but for the case where 75% of memory was used, I'm surprised, I would expect a slowdown but not a crash.
(1) Is there anything special about the way Firefox is starting up, for example, with "Compatibility" options set in the program shortcut, or through a security sandbox, that might change how it interacts with Windows to request more memory?
(2) Your crash report shows nearly 20 extensions active. If you discover a site or set of actions that reliably cause the crash, could you try it in Firefox's Safe Mode? That's a standard diagnostic tool to deactivate extensions and some advanced features of Firefox. More info: Troubleshoot Firefox issues using Safe Mode.
If Firefox is running: You can restart Firefox in Safe Mode using
Help > Restart with Add-ons Disabled (Flash and other plugins still run)
If Firefox is not running: You can start Firefox in Safe Mode by holding down the Shift key when starting Firefox.
In the small dialog that should appear, click "Start in Safe Mode" (not Reset)
(3) Strange graphical anomalies can indicate an incompatibility with your graphics card drivers. The standard workaround is to disable Firefox's use of hardware acceleration.
orange Firefox button (or Tools menu) > Options > Advanced
On the "General" mini-tab, uncheck the box for "Use hardware acceleration when available"
This takes effect the next time you exit and restart Firefox.
Oh yeah I forgot to mention I've tried disabling hardware acceleration in both browser settings and in flash object settings, but to no avail. And yes I have roughly 18 or so extensions, but I haven't changed them much in the last year, and they didn't cause problems before roughly a year ago, and plus I have troubleshooted them all and they've all been disabled at one point but the crashes still occurred.
And after every crash, firefox almost always goes to the couldn't-restore-session page, and it is a little slow starting up.
On a positive note, taking a look at the crashes there are bugs that are fixed in the next nightly build 31:
- 1st crash fixed in 31https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=984379
- 2nd crash high memory crash bug https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=986502 Graphics- (you have already tried to disable acceleration, but can you check to make sure your drivers for the graphics on your computer are up to date? Upgrade your graphics drivers to use hardware acceleration and WebGL )
- 3rd crash memory crash on startup
- 4th is the same as the 2nd, D2D+ is on
However the others are crashing with acceleration on, most likely you turned it off after though and it crashed again. The version you are using, version 30 is still in development, so there will be more changes as you use it. Any information in regards to what you were doing right before the crash will help get a steps to reproduce to the two bugs attached to the second and third reports.
In a run window :
- On 32-bit Windows: "C:\Program Files\Mozilla Firefox\firefox.exe" -p
- On 64-bit Windows: "C:\Program Files (x86)\Mozilla Firefox\firefox.exe" -p
Thank you for your help on this issue.
Modified by guigs
This has been happening since long before I was on Aurora 29 (I'm now on 30) (and yes, that includes it happening on Aurora 29). I said in my original post I can be doing anything from watching a YouTube video to browsing Wikipedia, Facebook, a text-only website, anything, and it will crash. It froze with the effects described above just a minute ago but luckily I caught a screen capture of it for you to see (and luckily it didn't crash, but this is what I will see moments before a crash):
(The yellow smudges are where I've censored the image - I was watching EDM music and minimally clothed girls tend to appear in the thumbnails of mixes)
I have a feeling there is no way it could be showing these flash objects without building up a temporary storage of them somewhere (probably not purposely or not as it's supposed to do) and this overload could be causing the crash. I clear cache multiple times as I thought that would clear it but it has no effect.
This is what happens after it crashes: http://i.imgur.com/UmH7Flh.png
When it crashed this time I was not using Firefox. I wasn't even on the window.
I tried to do that mozregression thing but it was too complicated for me. I updated to the recent Aurora 31 but the problem STILL persists. And I caught another screenshot of a freeze happening just so you get the idea: http://prntscr.com/3fyyva
The plugin container crashed and sometimes it is freezing, even after turning off hardware acceleration.
The second bug has a new update on it that says an add on was developed to restart the browser when the virtual memory is about to cause a crash Prevent Out of Virtual Memory however it is not entirely compatible.
It is possible to bypass the plugin container, Youtube video on how to do this at least for the time being.
Are you also receiving new crashes with the new version: crashes [Bug 984379 NS_ABORT_OOM(unsigned int) | nsAString_internal::Assign(wchar_t const*, unsigned int because of loading streaming videos] may need examples of this issue.
Thank you for the screenshots as well.
I just tried the plugincontainer.exe disabling thing and will wait to see a result.
These are all the latest crashes since 5th May.
bp-d968e5fc-aa31-4c36-8162-4e6bd2140511 11/05/2014 2:44 PM bp-cb67fb91-34ca-49b8-ad40-b5fbc2140510 10/05/2014 9:30 PM bp-937664d3-5ec9-4864-bda8-8cac02140510 10/05/2014 1:59 PM bp-30756e83-df6b-4adb-bce2-93e592140509 09/05/2014 4:14 PM bp-d4a0d443-0c0a-49ac-8f1d-316222140508 08/05/2014 5:12 PM 43721b5b-6d3f-44de-a22c-62908fa5544c 07/05/2014 4:49 PM 1463ee5e-6394-4b6a-9568-8ba3bf5ed420 07/05/2014 4:49 PM bp-hr-20140506-7347f037-13d7-4996-b6bd-6c74b747be1d 06/05/2014 6:51 PM bp-fdfbae5c-e93d-4862-aaec-d27bf2140505 05/05/2014 2:48 PM
And I caught another screenshot of a catastrophic crash (the crash happened seconds after I took this shot: http://i.imgur.com/DhEIg5Q.png (personal info is whited out).
Oh yeah and caution of obscene language in the user comments of the crashes, at times when I'm in the middle of watching a YouTube video or doing something that takes ages to load back, I get pretty angry.
Understandable, sorry for the frustration, thank you for the screenshot and the crash reports. I was looking at these yesterday and was not sure what I could add. The version 31.0a2 is crashing.
- [996303 NEW --- crash in NS_ABORT_OOM(unsigned int) | AppendUTF8toUTF16(nsACString_internal const&, nsAString_internal&)]
- [Bug 990156 - OOM crashes on 30.0a2 (see attached memory reports]
I added some troubleshooting info to the second bug, as it may still be memory. Have you updated your extensions?
Actually I haven't updated my addons in a while, thank you for reminding me. Although I did try disabling each one or multiple ones at a time and it didn't work. There wasn't one addon which I hadn't disabled, yet it still crashed.
Wait a minute, do you have an ativirus that might be blocking the Flash plugin? Adobe Flash plugin has crashed - Prevent it from happening again
One of the crashes is in encoding transfer? utf8 to ustf18? I might be going crazy as well....
Would that not disable flash altogether? I haven't changed around my antivirus settings for years and this problem only started last year. Flash works fine, although a bit choppy when first playing videos and can lag sometimes and when I pause a YouTube video sometimes the video will do a strange thing where it will play faster for a few seconds to catchup with the lag, and only then pause. And also sometimes I do get flash plugin crashes, but normally that's when I have a lot of videos open, but it can happen when I have only 1 or 2 strangely.
And I also have that thing where the addons list says I have Flash 12 AND Flash 13 installed and activated at the same time, but when I disable one, it disabled the other.
I fail to see what plugincontainer helps in the diagnosis of this issue.
That said, the variety of crash signatures suggests the possibility that the problem is not Firefox. Therefore, I suggest a) post a crash ID that occurred with Firefox in safe mode https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/troubleshoot-firefox-issues-using-safe-mode b) if it still crashes, install flashblock addon and run with that. If it only crashes when you permit a flash image, then you're on to something.
> Oh yeah and caution of obscene language in the user comments ... it would be very appreciated if you could eliminate that, and just stick to the facts
p.s. how many tabs and windows are open?
Sorry for the late reply, normally I have roughly 30-40 something tabs open which I am fully aware is quite a lot, but understand that these crashes have happened when I've had as little as 10-15 open. I have only just seen your suggestion about Safe Mode so I shall try that, and I have ceased the language in the reports.