Windows 10 reached EOS (end of support) on October 14, 2025. If you are on Windows 10, see this article.

Search Support

Avoid support scams. We will never ask you to call or text a phone number or share personal information. Please report suspicious activity using the “Report Abuse” option.

Learn More
Solved Archived

Two gmail accounts, same settings, can only get IMAP mail from one

curtin.me

I use 2 different gmail accounts for different purposes. I get mail for AccountA via IMAP on Thunderbird, no problem, and have for years. For over a year now I've been unable to collect mail for my second-string address, AccountB, on Thunderbird, and have had to get it in the browser.

I've finally decided to do something about this. I removed AccountB from Thunderbird & set it up again. I'm using the exact same settings (in Thunderbird and in Gmail) that I do for AccountA, the only difference is the password. I've double-checked the password, too. But when I try to connect, I get a pop-up:


titled: Enter credentials for AccountB@gmail.com on imap.gmail.com [a very long URL which I've copied & saved] page from Google:

400. That's an error. The server cannot process the request because it is malformed. It should not be retried. That's all we know.


Thanks a heap, guys!

Is this problem coming from Thunderbird, or from Google? What do I do now?

Thanks,

MEC

I use 2 different gmail accounts for different purposes. I get mail for AccountA via IMAP on Thunderbird, no problem, and have for years. For over a year now I've been unable to collect mail for my second-string address, AccountB, on Thunderbird, and have had to get it in the browser. I've finally decided to do something about this. I removed AccountB from Thunderbird & set it up again. I'm using the exact same settings (in Thunderbird and in Gmail) that I do for AccountA, the only difference is the password. I've double-checked the password, too. But when I try to connect, I get a pop-up: ---------- titled: Enter credentials for AccountB@gmail.com on imap.gmail.com [a very long URL which I've copied & saved] page from Google: 400. That's an error. The server cannot process the request because it is malformed. It should not be retried. That's all we know. ----------- Thanks a heap, guys! Is this problem coming from Thunderbird, or from Google? What do I do now? Thanks, MEC

All Replies (3)

Chosen Solution

Are cookies accepted in TB Settings/Privacy & Security? It's necessary for OAuth2 authentication.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Thunderbird/comments/15tgopz/trouble_with_thunderbird_with_gmail_accounts/

The only cookies I'm allowing are from accounts.google.com. Remember, I'm picking up mail from AccountA@gmail.com with no problem, it's only AccountB@gmail.com that's giving me trouble--even though all settings are identical except the password.

ETA OK, I've now allowed all cookies, it let me log on (2-factor auth), things are DLing. After it's all set up I'll disallow cookies except from accounts.google.com, see if I can still pick up mail.

Modified by curtin.me

OK! The trick is to turn on "Accept all cookies" only for the *first*, login connection, where you go through 2-factor authorization. Then you toggle it off and keep accounts.google.com as the exception.

Thank you so much!

MEC