Avatar for Username

Search Support

Avoid support scams. We will never ask you to call or text a phone number or share personal information. Please report suspicious activity using the “Report Abuse” option.

Learn More

This thread was archived. Please ask a new question if you need help.

Thunderbird sometimes uses wrong "from" address in reply

  • 2 replies
  • 2 have this problem
  • 16 views
  • Last reply by efornes

Nigel123
Nigel123
more options

I'm using Thunderbird 60.9.0 on Windows 7. I have an email account with a number of identities, one of which is set as my default address, which is not the address which I use to login to the mail servers I use. When I send a new message, the default is selected as the "from" address, and when I reply to a message sent to any of the identities, that one is selected, which is correct. However, if I reply to a message sent to an address that is not one of the identities I have configured (most often this will be a message sent by someone else to a mailing list to which I subscribe, and the "to" address will be that of the list server), the "from" address selected is NOT the default, but the one used to login to the servers. This seems incorrect to me; is there any workaround, please, or could it be logged as a bug?

I'm using Thunderbird 60.9.0 on Windows 7. I have an email account with a number of identities, one of which is set as my default address, which is not the address which I use to login to the mail servers I use. When I send a new message, the default is selected as the "from" address, and when I reply to a message sent to any of the identities, that one is selected, which is correct. However, if I reply to a message sent to an address that is not one of the identities I have configured (most often this will be a message sent by someone else to a mailing list to which I subscribe, and the "to" address will be that of the list server), the "from" address selected is NOT the default, but the one used to login to the servers. This seems incorrect to me; is there any workaround, please, or could it be logged as a bug?

All Replies (2)

Nigel123
Nigel123 Question owner
more options

A little more information: if the "from" address of the message I'm replying to is one of my identities (and the "to" address is not), then the "from" address of the reply is the same as that of the message being replied to. The situation I mentioned happens when neither address is one of my identities.

efornes
efornes
more options

I have 13 email accounts set up in Thunderbird, one of them belonging to my wife (we work together! she has mine too ;))

I noticed today, when I was replying to HER from an email account (btw the one she has in her computer too), that the Reply to field is WRONG! I was replying to my self!... and the FROM field was... my wife!! very stupid and very annoying

I had to delete her account from my Thunderbird and now all works fine...

I thought it all has to do with the "me" "Mine" "myself" thing in the address but I disabled mail.showcondensed.address and the issue was still there...

I've seen this is a VERY OLD BEHAVIOR IN THUNDERBIRD!!! I know thunderbird is a free app... but how come is not yet solved... maybe we should pay for thunderbird ;)

happy new year 2020 ;)